Come Visit Us! ​

Due to a fire, we are temporarily located at 5612 East Washington Street, while our original location is being remodeled. 

Due to Covid-19, we are currently open Fridays and Saturdays from 12pm-6pm, and Sundays from 12pm-4pm. We will be open by appointment the rest of the week! To schedule an appointment, call us at 317.602.5442 or send us a message through the contact page. For the safety of our customers, we will be wearing masks, and hope you will too. When you arrive, you will be offered gloves, masks, and hand sanitizer for your convenience. We will continue to host Facebook Live shopping events, take orders, and make deliveries. Sign up for our email list to keep up to date on the reopening of the original store!​

The Story: 

Black Sheep Gifts opened in May 2010. After moving to the Irvington neighborhood in 2000, owner Lisa Bennett said it was hard to find a good greeting card. Following the death of her father, Frank, she decided to invest his life insurance money and become an entrepreneur. ​

Where did the name come from?
The business name is registered with the state as Thanks, Frank LLC as a tribute to her father. Lisa was known as the black sheep of her family, but on her father's side, there are only black sheep with a few grey in the herd. Hence the name Black Sheep Gifts.