The Benton House

5626 East Washington Street

Indianapolis, IN  46219

317.602.5442


 317 602 . 5442

Monday - Thursday  11 am - 7pm

Friday/Saturday  11 am - 8 pm

Sunday  Noon - 5pm

Fun place!  Unusual gift items ...

Don't know what to get a friend or family member for a gift? 

 Stop in here!

Lisa

Parking is available along the front entrance on E. Washington Street, and in the parking lot directly behind our building ... Where you can come right in through the back door entrance.


About Us

We're not shy about Poo

Everybody does it, right?  How about a bathroom guestbook and our PooPouri Bathroom Spray®

Spritz the bowl before you go ... and no one will ever know.  Leave some "reading material" for your guests as well!

• Live here

• Work here

• Play here

L

O

O

K


U

P


"I always said I was the black sheep of the family,

but we joke that on my dad's side, there are no white sheep,

just a herd of black sheep ... and a few gray! 

The Legend Classic Irvington Cafe

Visit

Us

U

M

B

R

E

L

L

A


C

E

I

L

I

N

G

Black Sheep Gifts has an assortment of adorable kitschy things!  

Gifts for all ages ... Candies to children's toys,  housewares, jewelry,

wine & cocktails  and so much more!

Antique Mall of Irvington by Jack & Jill

     After living in Irvington for several years, and not able to find a local shop to even purchase a greeting card, we knew this was the time and certainly, the need, to bring a gift shop to our historic neighborhood.  

     Thus, the eclectic gift shop Black Sheep Gifts was created. We can take you from cradle to grave, selling everything from baby items and toys, to kitchen items, seasonal, and even "adult only" refrigerator magnets (ask to see these .... they're behind the counter!)  

     Our desire is for the store to be fun for everyone ... the kids especially enjoy our Candy Wall.

​We felt that if we put a place to shop the "Irvingtonians" and Indianapolis folks would fully support it - and they have!  

HISTORIC IRVINGTON |  INDIANAPOLIS, IN

| 317 |  602.5442

BLACK SHEEP Gifts

gifts greeting cards holidays